A Nantucket sale rewards preparation more than almost any market we know. The buyer is often arriving from off-island with limited time, a sharp attorney and a long list of questions, and the house that has its answers ready is the house that closes. This is how we take a property from the first conversation to the closing table.
Price from evidence, not the assessment
The town's assessed value is a tax number. It is calculated on a schedule, by formula, across the whole island, and on Nantucket it has little to do with what a specific house will sell for in a specific season. We never price from it, and we will tell you if someone else does.
Instead, pricing comes from sales evidence in LINK, the island's MLS: what comparable houses have actually closed for, how long they took, and where the market is moving now rather than a year ago. We show you that evidence, address by address, and we arrive at a price together. A number that is right from the start sells faster and for more than one that is corrected later.
Assemble the files before the sign goes up
Every serious buyer on this island will ask for the same things, and the seller who already has them wins time and credibility.
- Title 5. If the house is on septic, the inspection is required at transfer, and the report's bedroom count should match what the listing claims. A system that needs work is better discovered now than during a buyer's contingency period.
- HDC history. Certificates of appropriateness for past exterior work, and clarity on anything that was done without one.
- Flood and elevation. The FEMA zone, an elevation certificate if one exists, and the insurance history.
- Permits and plans. Building permits, surveys, and the plot plan, so a buyer's attorney has nothing to chase.
We put this together with you in the first weeks, and we keep it in a form that can be sent to a buyer's team the same day they ask.
Prepare the house to be photographed
Most Nantucket buyers see a house on a screen first, from a city hundreds of miles away. That first impression is made by photography, and photography is made by preparation. We walk the property room by room and outside, make a short list of what should be done and what should not, and bring in staging where it will earn its cost. Then we bring in a professional photographer, and where the property warrants it, drone and video.
Marketing that leaves the island
A listing in LINK reaches every Nantucket agent within the hour. Reaching the buyer who has not yet called a Nantucket agent is the second job. Our marketing runs through the national portals, through eXp's network across the country, through our own sites and through direct outreach to the buyers and agents we already know are looking. Each of the five of us brings our own reach, and every listing gets all of it.
Timing and the seasons
There is no single right month to list. Spring brings the deepest buyer pool and the most competition; summer shows the house at its best and brings buyers who are already here; fall closings suit sellers whose rental season has just ended. If the house is rented, we plan showings around the bookings and respect the tenants, because a well-run rental is part of what a buyer is paying for. We will give you a frank view of the timing for your particular property.
Showings, offers and negotiation
Showings on an island mean coordinating boats, flights and sometimes a buyer who is seeing the house on an agent's phone. We handle the logistics and the follow-up, and we report back after every one. When offers arrive, we read them for more than the number: the deposit, the contingencies, the financing, the closing date and the buyer's ability to perform. The best offer is the one that closes on your terms, and negotiating toward it is the heart of what we do.
The Land Bank fee and closing costs
The Nantucket Islands Land Bank transfer fee is paid by the buyer, not the seller, so it does not come out of your proceeds; it does affect how buyers budget, which is worth knowing when you set a price. Your side of the closing is the attorney, the deed stamps, any mortgage payoff and the brokerage fee, all of which we lay out for you in writing before you list so there are no surprises on the settlement statement.
What we ask of you
Honesty about the house, patience with the preparation, and a willingness to price from what the evidence says. In return we bring the island knowledge, the network, and the attention a sale here deserves. Ask what your home is worth and we will start with the evidence.
