Small boats pulled up on the harbor beach at Monomoy on a still evening

NANTUCKET NEIGHBORHOODS

Monomoy

Harbor views and long lawns to the water, ten minutes from Main Street.

See every Monomoy listing on the register →

Monomoy is a short, extraordinary stretch of harborside land beginning where Town ends: the first true estate neighborhood east of the core, where lawns run to the water and the Town skyline becomes the evening view. Buyers here are usually looking at the top of the market, and the neighborhood rarely advertises itself.

The combination

What a Monomoy buyer is purchasing exists almost nowhere else on the island: estate scale and real privacy, calm harbor water for boats and swimming children, and a ten-minute run to Main Street by car or by boat. The neighborhoods further out trade proximity for seclusion. Monomoy declines the trade, and it prices accordingly.

In LINK's data it is a small area with outsized numbers: few sales, high prices, and a pricing logic driven almost entirely by the waterfront. Frontage, dock rights and elevation each carry their own premium, and reading the comparables here takes genuine local fluency.

How the market works

A meaningful share of Monomoy transactions never reach a public listing. Relationships determine access, and the houses that do list often come with a story already attached. Owners rent selectively if at all; the value is held in the asset rather than the season. Harborfront scarcity has historically insulated the neighborhood through broader cycles.

The houses

Shingled estates on the water, with guest houses, pools and docks where the permits allow, and a second tier of substantial homes on the streets behind with harbor glimpses and the same address. The harbor side is calm, but the land is low in places, and the flood maps matter on the frontage.

What to know before you buy

Dock and mooring rights are specific to the parcel and should be confirmed in writing, not assumed from the view. Parts of Monomoy are on town sewer and parts are not, and the difference matters for an estate-scale house. Shoreline work, from a pier to a stabilized bank, runs through state and town wetland review. And because so much trades off-market, a buyer who wants Monomoy should say so early.

What is publicly listed is on the register. Shimmo continues along the harbor to the east, and Town is the neighbor to the west.

ON THE MARKET

Listings in Monomoy

Every active Monomoy listing, from LINK, refreshed daily.

ALL MONOMOY LISTINGS →

Nothing in Monomoy is listed on LINK today. See every active listing on the island, or tell us what you're looking for and we'll watch for it.

Ask us about Monomoy.

Five agents, one island, and a direct line to each of us. Tell us the house you're imagining; we'll tell you where it is.

START THE CONVERSATION